The 7th grade Language Arts teachers are covering this assignment in a step-by-step, formulaic process. Why? Analyzing literature can be difficult. The purpose here is to expose students to this type of writing.
I don't expect students to write complete papers. The lesson teaches three basic requirements: 1)students write a thematic statement, 2) students summarize a part of the story that points to the theme, and 3) students use a quote and page number from their story as proof.
On the handouts link, there is a paper titled "How to Write a Theme Statement for Literature." We covered that today. After step 1, students wrote a thematic sentence. After step 2, I asked them to draw a box around their thematic statement. Those are the words that follow after the word therefore. Step 3 was most difficult. It asks, now that you have a theme for your story, what parts of the story go with this theme? Go ahead and summarize those parts. Do not quote, only summarize.
Q: If one of my theme words was love, why can't I repeat it in my thematic statement? It's a really long sentence.
A: Because. No, seriously, if you keep using the same word, your thematic statement sounds confusing and repetitive. It's a poor writing practice.
Q: Is this like a lesson or a moral?
A: No. A theme is neither lesson nor moral. It is a statement about human nature.
Q: Does my theme have to fit my story?
A: Yes. If your theme needs rewriting, do so. I wrote an example theme statement for the short story "Seventh Grade" but it sounded mean, so I rewrote it.
Some classes started filling out the next page. It's also in the handouts link and it's titled "Step-by-Step How to Write a Literary Analysis Paper." We'll continue working with this paper tomorrow.
Overall, students are doing well. I don't expect to see a full paper by Friday. I do expect to see two, maybe three paragraphs done correctly.
Mr. E.