Student:______________________#___ Project Title:________________________ Experimental yes no

-20

	Unsatisfactory (7 points)	Satisfactory (8 points)	Good (9 points)	Excellent (10 points)
Creativity	Sloppy lettering, unbalanced layout, poor use of color (or none), layout makes project difficult to understand, no clear presentation of data	Missing 3 or 4 of the following: Neat Lettering, appealing design, good use of color, trim or accents, balanced layout, graphs/charts make data easier to understand	Missing 1 or 2 of the following: Neat Lettering, appealing design, good use of color, trim or accents, balanced layout, graphs/charts make data easier to understand	Neat Lettering, appealing design, good use of color, trim or accents, balanced layout, graphs/charts make data easier to understand
Completeness (having all the parts)	Missing any one of these: Data, background info, conclusion, procedure	Missing more than two of the minor parts (those not mentioned in the 2 point section)	May be missing one or two of the following: references, problem, title, abstract	No parts missing (per handouts and website)
Scientific merit	Lacking scientific soundness. Missing 3 or more of these: unsupported conclusion, unclear procedure, uncontrolled variable, insufficient background info, limited data	Scientifically sound with the exception of 2 of these: unsupported conclusion, unclear procedure, uncontrolled variable, insufficient background info, limited data	Scientifically sound with the exception of 1 of these: unsupported conclusion, unclear procedure, uncontrolled variable, insufficient background info, limited data	Isolated variables, plentiful data, conclusions well-supported by data, well-defined procedures, background info develops ideas