GLUE STICKS!!! 
colored printer paper
stickers
kid friendly magazines (used is good too!)
fish food (tropical)
Fish: Mollies, Guppies, or Neon Tetras for my tank (or gift card to 
Petsmart)
Fish tank filters (Tetra Whisper Bio-Bag size LARGE)
cool magnets
reed diffusers
anything Mary Engelbreit (my favorite)
Mrs. McSpadden's Adopt A Classroom Donations (see Homepage link)